Why Black Superheroes Matter

After five decades as sidekicks, secondary characters and niche titles, the black superhero’s time has finally come.

Next month Marvel releases its eagerly awaited Black Panther movie, centered on a young African king who doubles as a clawed, catsuit-clad crimefighter. 

Last week CW and Netflix unveiled Black Lightning, an African-American educator with electrical superpowers. Add in Netflix’s Luke Cage and that’s three African-American-led superhero titles in 18 months – a situation previously unimaginable.

The timing could not be better in terms of US race relations, which are more charged now than they have been in generations. Recent developments could be seen as having paved the way: the Black Lives Matter movement, debates over representation sparked by the #OscarSoWhite debacle, the resurgence of white nationalism and institutional racism resulting from Donald Trump’s presidency.

But the trend is driven by commercial concerns as much as cultural ones. Cheo Hodari Coker, producer and writer of Luke Cage, said recently: “The only colour that really matters is green [backdrop for CGI scenes] … I don’t know if it’s as much altruism as much as it is a combination of being commercially viable, the stories are interesting, the music pops and people think, ‘Why not now?’”

The superhero market is Hollywood’s primary earner: in the US alone, superhero movies earned more than $2bn in 2017. After a decade of titles led by white males, however, studios are aware that viewer fatigue could burst the bubble. They are constantly looking for new ways to reinvigorate the genre and, mindful of their global audience, attract viewers of all colours. 

Last year’s Wonder Woman movie proved that a female-led superhero title is now a viable option; this year looks set to do the same for black superheroes. But questions remain about how “political” mainstream audiences want their comic book entertainment to be. 

Black Lightning, which began in the US last week, overtly addresses the racial climate. In its opening minutes, the first episode sketches out a landscape of gang violence, institutional racism and street protests, quotes Martin Luther King and fellow civil rights activist Fannie Lou Hamer, namechecks Harriet Tubman, and plays Billie Holliday’s protest song Strange Fruit.

“We’ve reached a time where people are hungry for diversity… a lot of art comes out of that.” Cress Williams

Its hero, Jefferson Pierce, played by Cress Williams, has the power to control electricity and shoot lightning bolts from his hands, but when the story begins he is in retirement as a school principal in the fictional city of Freeland.

In an intense early scene, Pierce’s car is pulled over by white cops as he drives home with his two daughters. As they train their guns on him, and give no reason, his eyes begin to glow blue as his rage builds and his powers charge up. When those daughters are abducted by a local gang – led by an African-American kingpin with albinism – Pierce steps back into costume.

“In a simplified sense, you could look at Jefferson Pierce as Martin Luther King and Black Lightning as Malcolm X,” says Williams. 

“Non-violence is a great philosophy, and should always be the first resort, but sometimes you have to protect yourself. Sometimes you have to mess things up, be a little bit more active to get things done. The show hopefully poses that question.”

Luke Cage, whose Netflix series began in September 2016, also reluctantly brings his superpowers to bear on the organised African-American crime ripping his Harlem community apart. 

It operates at a blaxploitation-filtered remove from the present day, but still addresses issues of politics, racism and African-American history. Cage, played by Mike Colter, is set to return for a second season later this year.

Black Panther is a more fantastical prospect, but no less significant a cultural moment. Expensive, action-packed and effects-heavy, it is led by black talent, including director Ryan Coogler and actors Chadwick Boseman, Michael B Jordan and Lupita Nyong’o. The story’s fictional setting of Wakanda is a prosperous, technologically advanced African nation – a marked contrast to previous, stereotypical depictions of the continent.

Bringing these black superheroes to the foreground has been a long and strategic process. Most were created during an earlier time of African-American empowerment: the black power movement and the blaxploitation movie genre of the 1960s and 70s. 

Marvel comics introduced the character of Black Panther in 1966 (a few months before the launch of the Black Panther party). He was followed by Falcon (1969), Luke Cage (1972) and Storm (1975). Black Lightning began in DC comics in 1977.

Even before the superhero movie took over Hollywood, Marvel (now owned by Disney) had set about diversifying its overwhelmingly white stable. A key change was the character Nick Fury, head of fictional spy agency SHIELD and chief of superhero team the Avengers. 

In his first incarnation, Fury was an archetypal tough, caucasian ex-soldier with an eyepatch (David Hasselhoff played Fury in a 1998 TV movie). In 2000 Marvel reinvented Fury as an African American, specifically modelled on Samuel L Jackson, who went on to play the character in the movies.

Marvel continued to introduce black superheroes in its movies, but (with the exception of Wesley Snipes’s Blade trilogy in the late 1990s/early 2000s) only in secondary roles. Iron Man had his accomplice Rhodey (played by Terrence Howard, then Don Cheadle), Captain America had Falcon (Anthony Mackie), Halle Berry played the X-Men’s Storm. 

Other formerly white characters were cast with black actors, including Idris Elba as Norse god Heimdall in Thor, and Michael B Jordan as the Fantastic Four’s Human Torch.

Both Black Panther and Luke Cage were carefully integrated into pre-existing storylines. Boseman’s Black Panther made his debut in Captain America: Civil War; Mike Colter’s Luke Cage first appeared in Marvel/Netflix show Jessica Jones. 

Following Cage’s solo series, he and Jones joined forces in ensemble series The Defenders, just as Black Panther is set to figure in Marvel’s grand crossover movie Avengers: Infinity War, this summer. This embedding strategy subtly signals that these are not exclusively characters for “minority” audiences. White viewers have been brought along with them.

Regardless of the motivations, Black Panther, Black Lightning and Luke Cage suggest that comic-book movies can continue to function as a form of global diversity-awareness training.

“We’ve reached a time where people are hungry for diversity,” says Cress Williams. He sees the rise of black superheroes as “a backlash to what happened, politically, a year ago. I think what happened in our society revealed that we weren’t as far along as we thought, so people are really hungry to move it along, to evolve us faster. And a lot of art comes out of that.”

Certainly there is more work to be done. Asian and Latino heroes are still extremely thin on the ground, as are female superheroes. Wonder Woman and Jessica Jones remain the only top-billed movie superheroines (discounting Halle Berry’s disastrous 2004 Catwoman). 

The next hurdle would be a black female superhero. With that in mind, it is significant that Black Lightning’s two daughters possess superpowers of their own, as could Luke Cage’s accomplice Misty Knight and Black Panther’s younger sister, Shuri. The ground is already being prepared.

Black Lightning launches on Netflix on 23 January. Black Panther is released in the UK on 12 February.

Steve Rose The Guardian
January 20, 2018 19.05 EST